Amnesty International calls for U.S. restraint

Social justice news
November 2001

Major appeal planned for Afghanistan refugees
Amnesty International calls for U.S. restraint
Renewed Mideast violence called intolerable
Refugee camp offers glimpse of growing crisis
Bishops' meeting to look at Africa and aftermath of September 11
Earth Summit's declaration of interdependence

Amnesty International calls for U.S. restraint
Amnesty International (AI) is calling on the U.S. military to strengthen measures to ensure that civilians are not killed as a result of their military action, to investigate thoroughly reports of such incidents and make public their findings. The organization is also calling for a moratorium on the use of cluster bombs.

"Every civilian victim of the ongoing conflict in Afghanistan adds to years of killings, repression, displacement, and hunger," an Amnesty International spokesperson said in a press release.

"The human cost of the conflict continues to mount and increasing reports of civilian casualties allegedly arising from U.S.-led military action are a cause for grave concern. U.S. officials have admitted that a number of civilian targets have been hit as a result of error, however the lack of public information on such attacks is disturbing."

It is not possible to independently verify the 1,500 civilian deaths reported by Taliban authorities because of the limited access to Afghanistan for impartial observers, but reports from UN officials, humanitarian NGOs, and refugees fleeing to Pakistan raise enough concern, say AI officials, to call for an immediate and full investigation into what may have been violations of international humanitarian law such as direct attacks on civilian objects or indiscriminate attacks. U.S. officials charge that Taliban civilian casualty figures are exaggerated.

Amnesty International has already asked the U..S authorities to investigate a number of attacks, including the air attack on October 12 on the village of Khorum, where a number of civilians were reportedly killed; and two air attacks on International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) warehouses in Kabul, in which one Afghan civilian was injured.

The organization has also expressed concern at an attack on an Afghan radio station mentioned at a Pentagon news briefing on October 11. On October 16 Secretary of Defence Rumsfeld indicated that radio stations and the television station were hit because they were "propaganda vehicles for the Taliban leadership". However, Amnesty International considers civilian radio and television stations to be civilian objects even when they are "propaganda vehicles."

AI argues that U.S.-led forces should take sufficient precautions to protect civilians in selecting military objectives and means of attack and should also desist from an attack if it becomes apparent that the objective is not a military one, or the attack risks being disproportionate to the military objective.

AI is also concerned about the use of cluster bombs close to civilian areas and is calling for an immediate moratorium on their use, pending an international review of their use due to take place in December 2001 in Geneva at the Second Review Conference of the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.

Cluster bombs present a high risk of violating the prohibition of indiscriminate attack, because of the wide area covered by the numerous bomblets released. At least 5 percent of them do not explode upon impact becoming de facto anti-personnel mines and remaining a continued threat to people, including civilians on the move, who come into contact with them.

Just this week the UN Office of the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs reported that cluster bombs were dropped over a village near Herat, in Western Afghanistan. The village was littered with unexploded bomblets, restricting the movement of local people.
"If cluster bombs continue to be used, civilians will not only suffer now but for years to come," Amnesty International warned.

Amnesty International has also called on the Taliban to take immediate action to prevent and repress serious violations of humanitarian law. Following a public statement on October 10 by al-Qa'ida spokesman Sulayman Abu Ghaith, suggesting that his group has no intention of respecting the principle of distinction between civilians and the military, AI urged the Taliban to ascertain whether al-Qa'ida or other forces fighting alongside the Taliban have carried out or are planning to carry out direct attacks on civilians, such as the September 11 attacks in the United States.

Back to page top